By Deacon Fuad (Fred) Totah
Just when it didn’t seem it could get any worse, an article in the highly respected New England Journal of Medicine is floating an appalling expansion of physician-assisted suicide: death by organ donation.
Death by organ donation patients who have chosen euthanasia would be placed under anesthesia and, while unconscious, would die through the surgical removal of their vital organs.
Already the narrative on physician-assisted suicide — now legal in 13 states, including California, and in the District of Columbia — pushes the idea of not being a trouble or drain on either relatives or society as well as taking control of the end of life. The concept of death by organ donation adds another superficially appealing yet evil argument by putting forth the false idea that the death will be an actual good by giving life to someone in need of an organ transplant.
In California, the California Department of Public Health reported that 1,032 individuals died after self-administering physician-prescribed aid-in-dying drugs in 2024 — a 6.5% increase over the previous year. These sobering statistics reflect a growing willingness to view intentionally ending life as a response to suffering.
Catholics are called to respond with both compassion and fidelity to the Gospel of life to counter this narrative of hopelessness.
As members of Christ’s Church, we are called to proclaim the inherent dignity of every human person, accompany those who suffer with love and hope and bear witness to the Gospel truth that authentic compassion never consists in intentionally causing death.
St. Irenaeus famously wrote, “The glory of God is man fully alive.” This profound truth expresses the foundation of the Catholic understanding of human dignity: every person is sacred, every life has meaning and every human being remains worthy of love and care until natural death.
Modern medicine has accomplished extraordinary things. Organ transplantation has restored health and extended life for countless patients suffering from serious illnesses. Catholics rightly support these advances when they respect the dignity of the human person and the moral law.
Yet these same medical advances also present new ethical challenges. As society becomes increasingly accepting of physician-assisted suicide and euthanasia, questions arise about the true purpose of medicine and the meaning of authentic compassion.
These concerns have become even more urgent with the recent proposal titled “Death by Organ Donation,” which asks whether patients who have chosen euthanasia should be permitted to die through the surgical removal of their vital organs rather than through a lethal injection.
Although this proposal remains a theoretical academic discussion and is not current medical practice in the United States, it raises a profound moral question: Can an act that intentionally causes death ever be justified because it produces a beneficial outcome?
Organ Donation: A Gift of Love
The Catholic Church has long supported ethical organ donation. The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches: “Organ donation after death is a noble and meritorious act and is to be encouraged as an expression of generous solidarity” (CCC 2296).
St. John Paul II described organ donation as “a genuine act of love” because it allows one person, after death, to offer hope and healing to another.
For Christians, organ donation can reflect Christ’s own self-giving love. However, the Church teaches that this gift must always respect the dignity of both donor and recipient. The donor must already be dead — with the clear lifelessness of the body indicating that the separation of body and soul has occurred — and death must never be intentionally caused in order to obtain organs.
This principle is known as the “dead donor rule.” Vital organs may only be removed from someone who is already dead, and the removal of organs must never be the cause of death.
The Ethical Problem with “death by organ donation”
The proposed practice would reverse this principle. Instead of a person dying first and then becoming an organ donor, surgeons would remove vital organs while circulation continues. The removal of those organs would cause death.
Supporters of the proposal argue that it could increase the number and quality of organs available for transplantation while respecting the patient’s stated wishes. They appeal to personal autonomy and the desire to save other lives.
However, Catholic moral theology recognizes that a good intention cannot justify an immoral action. Saving the lives of transplant recipients is a tremendous good, but intentionally causing the death of an innocent person — even with consent — cannot become morally acceptable because others may benefit.
As St. Paul warns: “And why not do evil that good may come?” (Rom 3:8).
St. John Paul II reaffirmed this principle in “Veritatis Splendor,” teaching that some actions are wrong by their very nature, regardless of circumstances or intentions.
The distinction is crucial. A person who donates organs after death offers a gift. A person whose death is caused so that organs can be obtained is not giving a gift after death; rather, death has become the means to achieve another goal.
Human Beings Are Never Mere Resources
At the heart of this debate is a deeper question: How does society understand human dignity?
A purely utilitarian approach measures human worth according to usefulness, independence or social benefit. Such a view risks seeing the dying person primarily as a burden or as a source of biological resources.
The Catholic vision is radically different. Every person is created in the image and likeness of God (Gn 1:27). Human dignity does not disappear because someone is elderly, disabled, dependent, unconscious or approaching death. A person’s value is not determined by productivity, health or usefulness. The dying person remains a beloved child of God.
Compassion Means Accompaniment, Not Abandonment
The Church’s response to suffering is not indifference. Catholics are called to provide compassionate care, excellent hospice services, pain management, emotional support and spiritual accompaniment. Authentic compassion does not seek to eliminate suffering by eliminating the person who suffers. It means remaining present, sharing burdens and affirming that every life continues to have meaning.
Those involved in Catholic end-of-life ministry — chaplains, clergy, deacons, health care workers and families — have a sacred responsibility to remind the suffering:
You are not your illness.
You are not your disability.
You are not your dependence.
You remain a beloved person created by God.
Protecting the Culture of Life
The discussion surrounding physician-assisted suicide and proposals such as “death by organ donation” reflect a larger cultural question: Will medicine remain committed to healing and caring, or will it increasingly view death as a solution to suffering? Catholic bioethics calls for vigilance and compassion by defending several essential principles:
The inviolable dignity of every human person.
The prohibition against intentionally killing the innocent.
Respect for the dead donor rule.
Independent and morally certain determination of death.
Protection of vulnerable patients from pressure or coercion.
Continued development of compassionate hospice and palliative care.
The Church does not oppose medicine. Rather, it seeks to ensure that medicine remains faithful to its highest purpose: serving the human person.
Organ transplantation is a remarkable expression of charity when it follows death and respects human dignity. But organ donation must remain a gift of love, not a reason to intentionally cause death.
In an age tempted to measure human worth by efficiency and usefulness, the Catholic faith proclaims a timeless truth: every human person possesses an inviolable dignity because every person is created by God, redeemed by Christ, and called to eternal life. Authentic compassion does not hasten death but walks with the suffering person until natural death comes, surrounded by love, dignity and hope in the promise of Christ: “I am the resurrection and the life. Whoever believes in Me, even though he dies, will live’” (Jn 11:25).
Deacon Totah is the director of pastoral ministry and the director of the Office of Deacon Formation for the Archdiocese of San Francisco.